Class discussion
During the discussion in class when we were talking about how Nissenbaum approaches history compared to how history has been approached throughout our school experiences, one idea popped into my head.
The way Nissenbaum approaches history not only makes ordinary people from historical times more real, but its in a factual. Pretty much, the only way you could understand how ordinary people lived during the 19th century would have been by reading novels or other works of fiction. One major classic novel that comes to mind, especially when it comes to Christmas traditions, is Little Women. I remember reading Little Women and one scene/chapter that stayed with me was they way in which the family celebrated Christmas. It wasn't as big of a deal as it is today. The thing is, however, is that Little Women is a work of fiction. Although it was written during the 19th century and is obviously intertwined with various aspects of culture at that time, you still can't help but think its a work of fiction. Nissenbaum, however, used real people and their actual traditions and rituals. This has more validity because it is based on actual fact. Even though he approaches history on a more personal level than say text books do, it is still factual and you can't help but take every word seriously and valid.
The one thing that I enjoy with the approach Nissenbaum takes is that it gives Little Women, one of my favorite books, validity.
I dont know if I made any sense in this new post, but I just felt the need to get this out there. It was in my brain and I needed to get it out and analyze it. Please forgive me if I dont make any sense...
